EFTA00439470.pdf
PDF Source (No Download)
Extracted Text (OCR)
From: Will Ford <I
To: undisclosed-recipients:;
<
Bee: "
Subject: http://www.wsj.com/articles/what-to-tell-your-children-about-trump- 1479427835
Date: Fri, 18 Nov 2016 13:48:53 +0000
OPINION COLUMNISTS DECLARATIONS
What to Tell Your Children About
Trump
We are the world's oldest democracy, we are good people, and we've been
through shocks before.
Gr
By PEGGY NOONAN
Updated Nov. 17, 2016 7:22 MI. ET
396 COMMENTS
Eight points and two anecdotes as we continue to digest this astounding election.
EFTA00439470
You don't know a tree is hollow until you push hard against it and it falls. The
establishments of both parties did not know, a year ago, that they were hollow trees.
They thought themselves strong because they always had been, and people think
what has been true will continue. Then suddenly the tree is pushed and falls. To me
that is the symbol, the image of 2016: the hollowed trees and how easily they fell.
Election night 2016 was not like 1980. That year produced an outcome fully within
the political norms: a former two-term governor won the presidency. This year's
outcome went beyond all previous norms. Twenty-sixteen was like nothing in our
lifetimes. In the future people will say, "Where were you that election night?" the
way they do for other epochal moments.
Much of the mainstream, legacy media continues its self-disgrace. Having failed to
kill Donald Trump's candidacy they will now aim at his transition. Soon they will
try to kill his presidency. Any journalists who are judicious toward Trump, who
treat him fairly or even as a human being, are now accused of "normalizing" him.
This is a manipulation: It is a way of warning your colleagues to approach the
president-elect with the proper hostility or be scorned. None of this will do our
country any good.
MORE DECLARATIONS
What Comes After the Uprising Nov. 11. 2016
Democracy's Majesty and 2O16's
Indignity Nov. 3. 2016
The Great Disappointment of 2016 Oct. 27,
2016
Imagine a Sane Donald Trump oct. zo. 2016
The left is in enraged mourning.
A better way forward would be:
reflect, absorb, gather your
strength as the opposition,
constructively oppose. Lose the
hissing rancor. Use that energy
to rebuild your party.
Right now 60 million people are
very happy, and hopeful. They
haven't taken to the streets in elation, so we can't see them. They haven't broken
car windows in their joy. Respect their happiness.
This is my fear: The question we ask after every national election is, "Can we come
together?" The question this year is more, "Do we even want to come together?"
Have the two nations within our nation reached a point of permanent estrangement?
EFTA00439471
If the cultural left eases up and the economic right loosens up, maybe things can be
soothed.
I think many people intuitively sense this: The Trump era either really will work or
really won't. It's going to be something good or a disaster, but it won't be a
middling thing.
This big, burly country can take it either way. The proper attitude now? Give him a
chance, watch close, wish well. Cheer what's sound, criticize what isn't.
And this: trust America.
Five days after the election I met an Ethiopian immigrant on a street in Washington.
We got to talking. He spoke of how bad it was in his old country, all the killing.
been here 15 years. "I love America," he said. "It gave everything to me." But
he was deeply concerned by the election. He has two sons, 8 and 6. The younger got
up Wednesday morning, saw the TV and burst into tears. Trump won! The boy calls
Trump "the mouth man." How could a bully be president? "He wept," said the
Ethiopian. "How do I explain it to him?"
I thought. Finally I said, "Tell him to trust America." Tell him that we are the
world's oldest democracy, that we are a good people, that we've been through
shocks and surprises, and that we have checks and balances. "If it turns out good," I
said, "we'll be happy. If it turns out really bad, America has a way of making your
stay in the White House not too long. But tell him to trust America as you did, and
it gave you everything."
He said
tell his son that. We warmly shook hands.
This isn't the first story of frightened children I've heard since the election. It's the
third. When I told it to a friend, also foreign-born, and so America-loving that he
chokes up when he quotes past presidents, he told me that his 5-year-old woke up
after the election and sobbed at the news.
Trump supporters feel that the left did this, demonizing Mr. Trump and making him
monstrous. There's some truth in that. But even truer is that Mr. Trump himself
EFTA00439472
scared the children of America for a solid year with his loud ways and rough
manner—"the mouth man."
What a great thing it would be if Donald Trump would take a day off from the
presidential transition, go to a series of schools, bring the press, and speak to
children, telling them that he has nothing in his heart but the desire to do good and
help people. "I have children and even grandchildren," he might say. "I love them. I
will do my best, and I love you."
Mr. Trump's people seem to me right now proud, exhausted and painfully aware
that they emerged victorious despite the daily pummeling from the establishment
and elite media. No one gave them a break.
And they're right. It was that way.
But it's not sissy-ish to respect peoples' anxieties. It doesn't legitimize your foes'
criticisms to show sensitivity. All presidents since Washington, "the father of our
country," have been seen as a national father figure. It grates on conservatives to
think like that. It grates on me. But that's inevitable for kids who see the president
on TV all the time in an un-parented country.
They need to see a little gentleness and good intent. Their parents would appreciate
it. And it's needed before the inauguration. Impressions will have hardened by then.
I end with a related personal note. I never interviewed Donald Trump throughout
this year's campaign. From the beginning he reminded me of men I grew up with,
Trumps with no money—loud, unsmooth, rough opinions. Where you came from
and who you were surrounded by has a bearing on your loyalties and can bend your
thinking. I judged that I'd see Mr. Trump most clearly from a middle distance. So I
didn't go, talk, interview. Six weeks ago I called a Trump staffer I'd interviewed to
check a quote. She returned my call from Trump Force One. We spoke, and then
suddenly the phone seemed to drop and I heard, "Who's that?" Then I heard,
"Peggy, this is Donald."
I won't quote exactly what was said. No one put it off the record, but it felt off the
record, and some of the conversation was personal. But I can describe it. He was
dignified, hilarious and modest. He told me that I'd sometimes been unfair to him,
EFTA00439473
sometimes mean, sometimes really, really mean, but that when I was he usually
deserved it, always appreciated it, and keep it up. He spoke of other things; he
characterized for me my career.
I'd heard of his charm offensive, but I'd be lying if I didn't say how charming,
funny and frank he was—and, as I say, how modest. How actually humble.
It moved me. And it hurt to a degree a few weeks later when I wrote in this space
that "Sane Donald Trump" would win in a landslide but that the one we had long
seen, the crazed, shallow one, wouldn't, and didn't deserve to.
Is it possible there are deeper reserves of humility, modesty and good intent lurking
around in there than we know? And maybe a toolbox, too, that can screw those
things together and produce something good?
Where there's life, there's hope. He's lively. Let's hope.
But whatever happens, trust America. She has a way of weathering through.
EFTA00439474
Document Preview
PDF source document
This document was extracted from a PDF. No image preview is available. The OCR text is shown on the left.
This document was extracted from a PDF. No image preview is available. The OCR text is shown on the left.
Document Details
| Filename | EFTA00439470.pdf |
| File Size | 279.1 KB |
| OCR Confidence | 85.0% |
| Has Readable Text | Yes |
| Text Length | 7,835 characters |
| Indexed | 2026-02-11T21:58:09.812024 |