DOJ-OGR-00017201.jpg

Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 767 Filed 08/10/22 Page 180 of 257 3014 LCKVMAX8 Rebuttal - Ms. Comey 1 Third. If Jane, Kate, Carolyn, and Annie really 2 believed that making up a story about Maxwell would somehow 3 benefit them, you better believe they would have told much 4 better lies. If they wanted to frame Maxwell, if they thought 5 doing so would somehow benefit her, they would put Maxwell in 6 way deeper. They would have said that Maxwell was in the room 7 every single time Jeffrey Epstein initiated sexual contact. 8 Jane, Carolyn, and Annie would have said that Maxwell 9 participated in all kinds of sex acts: Intercourse, oral sex, 10 you name it. That's not what they did. 11 Remember, Annie was so careful to make clear that the 12 defendant touched the tops of her breasts, but not her nipples. 13 Jane was careful to explain that Maxwell wasn't always in the 14 room, and that the only physical contact she remembers is the 15 defendant touching her breasts. 16 Carolyn described oral sex and intercourse involving 17 two other women, but with Maxwell it was just one time touching 18 her breasts. Her memory is that Maxwell mostly talked with 19 her, called to schedule appointments, invited her to travel. 20 And how about Kate? She never put Maxwell in the room 21 for a single sex act. She just remembered Maxwell walking her 22 to the door and leading her into that sexualized massage. And 23 remember, she said she was 17 when this happened. If she was 24 going to lie about her age, why wouldn't she make herself 25 younger? 16, 15, 14. SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C. (212) 805-0300 DOJ-OGR-00017201