DOJ-OGR-00021050.jpg

Case 22-1426, Document 59, 02/28/2023, 3475902, Page3 of 113 D. All counts fall within the scope of the NPA and must ToS EUSP SET ors cares seman. ene. cance ram. seem ns. em anne ee. te a at 40 POINT II ALL COUNTS ARE BARRED BY THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS. ........ccccccccesceeeeeseneeeseesseesacecaaecsaeceaecaeceaeeseeeeeeseeeenaeesaeeseesnneess 4] A. — Section 3283 Does Not Apply to the Mann Act Violations (Counts Three and Four) ..........ceccceeseeeesteeeereeeeaeees 43 B. — The District Court erred in applying § 3283 TEtLOACTIVELY oe eeecccceesseceessececseneeceeseeeecesaeeceecaeeessneeeeeeaeeeeseeeeess 52 1. Congress evinced an intent that § 3283 operate ONLY PrOspectiVely....... ce cccccceecceesssseceesteeeseteeeesteeeeseeeeess 54 2. The District Court’s application of § 3283 creates “impermissible retroactive effects” without authorization from Congress ...........::cccesseeeeees 58 C. Count Six is also barred by the Statute of Limitations ............. 62 POINT III DEFENDANT WAS DENIED HER CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT TO A FAIR AND IMPARTIAL JURY BECAUSE A JUROR MADE FALSE STATEMENTS IN VOIR DIRE AS TO MATERIAL FACTS THAT, IF KNOWN, WOULD HAVE PROVIDED A VALID BASIS TO REMOVE HIM FOR CAUSE. U.S. Const. amend. VI oie cece ccceeecccccceseececcccescececnsaeececeaaeeeecenaaeseeceaaaneeess 63 A. Tntroduction 2.00... cccceecccccceseeccceccescececcecseccecceaeececeaueeeeeeeaaeseceeees 63 B. — Applicable Law ........ccccccccccessseceeeseeeessaneeeesneesssaeeeessareeennnees 64 C. Juror No. 50’s False Responses Deprived Ms. Maxwell of her Constitutional Right to a Trial by an Impartial JULY oc cecccccccecessnececeensaeeeceesnaaeeeeeeceaeeecseceaaeeeceecunueeeeeecenaeeeeseneaaeees 65 1. Juror 50 Did Not Truthfully Answer Material Questions During VOIr Dire ....ceeccceccceecteeeseeesteeeeneeenaeees 65 D. | Under the McDonough Test, Juror 50’s Actual, Implied and Inferred Bias was established 00.0.0... cccccecceeeeeeeesteeeeneeeeaeees 66 1. The McDonough Test: The First Prong.............:ccceees 66 il DOJ-OGR-00021050