DocumentCloud_Epstein_Docs_p00822.png

Case 18-2868, Document 280, 08/09/2019, 2628232, Page3 of 74 B. Documentary Evidence also Shows that Defendant Trafficked Ms. Giuffre and Procured her for Sex with Convicted Pedophile Jeffrey Epstein while She Was Umer agen... eeeceeeseesescseesesesceceesescececsesseecscseseescsesesasscseeesaesseesesseeseesseeeeesaeseeee 2 1. The Flight Logs .....c.ccceeccsesssesesseseeseeecseeseeeceeeseeseeeseeaeeacnesaeeeceesesaeeesaeeatees 2 2. The Photographs ..........:.eccecsssesessesseseeecseeseeeceesseeaeeeseeaeeacseseeeececeeaeeeeseeaeees 3 3. The Victim Identification Letter... cece eeseeeeeeeececseeeeeeseneeeeaeseeees 5 4. New York Presbyterian Hospital Records...........ccecessesesseteeceeeereeeeeeeneeaees 5 5. Judith Lightfoot Psychological Records... cece eeeseeeeeeseseeeeseseeees 6 6. Message Pads... eee eescseceesesseeescseesescseesssscseeesaesceesesseseeesseseeesaeseeee 7 7. The Black Book... cecsesseeeecseesescseeeeesseseeesaeaseesecseseeesseseeesaeseeees 22 8. Sex Slave Amazon.com Book Receipt... ccccceceeseseeeseeseeeseseeeeseeeeeeees 23 9. Thailand Folder with Defendant’s Phone Numbet..............e eect 24 10. It is undisputed fact that the FBI report and the Churcher emails reference Ms. Giuffre’s accounts of sexual activity with Prince Andrew that she made in 2011, contrary to Defendant’s argument that Ms. Giuffre never made such claims until 2014.0... ee eeeeeeeeeeee 25 Cc. Defendant Has Produced No Documents Whatsoever That Tend to Show That She Did Not Procure Underage Girls For Jeffrey Epstein... eee 26 TH. == LEGAL STANDARD won cceecseecseseneeseseseceesesesesecsesesecaeaceeeecsesseasecseeeasseeetetaeseete 27 TV. LEGAL ARGUMENT ooo. ccecccecseececensescseseesescseeesesesececaeaceesecsesseasecseseeassseeeeraeseeees 27 A. Defendant is Liable for the Publication of the Defamatory Statement and Damages for Its Publication 1. Under New York Law, Defendant is liable for the media’s publication Of her press release. .......eceeeeesessesseseeecseeseeeceeeseeseeeeseeacaeeesseeeceeceesaeeeeeeaeees 28 2. Defendant is liable for the media’s publication of the defamatory StATCMENE. oe eee eeseeeeeeseeeeesescnececseseacseseeeescseeesaesceecesseseesscseeeasseeeeaas 32 B. Material Issues of Fact Preclude Summary Judgment... ee eeeeeeeteeeeeees 34 1. The Barden Declaration presents disputed issues of fact. ........ceeeeeeeeeee 34 ii