EFTA00731180.pdf
PDF Source (No Download)
Extracted Text (OCR)
Timcstamp: 5/25/2010 6:38 PM CDT
FINRA ARBITRATION
IN THE MATTER OF
FINANCIAL TRUST COMPANY, INC.,
THE C.O.U.Q. FOUNDATION, INC.,
v.
THE BEAR STEARNS COMPANIES,
BEAR STEARNS & CO., BEAR
STEARNS ASSET MANAGEMENT,
AND WARREN SPECTOR
Case No. 09-00979
Arbitrators:
Claimant's Response to The Bear Stearns Respondents'
First Request for the Production of Documents and Information
Claimants Financial Trust Company, Inc. and The C.O.U.Q. Foundation, Inc.
(collectively referred to as "FTC") hereby respond to The Bear Steams Respondents' First
Request for the Production of Documents and Information as follows:
OBJECTIONS TO DEFINITIONS AND INSTRUCTIONS
I.
FTC objects to any and all instructions or definitions which would require FTC to
respond in a manner beyond that required by the Code of Arbitration Procedure.
2.
FTC objects to the instructions and requests that seek documents that are not in
FTC's possession, custody or control.
3.
FTC objects to each request to the extent that it calls for any documents that were
prepared for or in anticipation of litigation, constitute attorney work-product, contain attorney-
client communications, or are otherwise subject to a privilege.
4.
FTC objects to the production of documents that contain proprietary and
confidential information belonging to third parties. FTC will not produce such documents
without the permission of the third party.
997243v1/011543
EFTA00731180
5.
FTC reserves the right to update its Responses as more information becomes
available to it.
6.
FISCO objects to the Requests for Information to the extent that they seek
information that exceeds the identification of "names, entities, and time periods related to the
disputes" as allowed by Rule 12507 of the Code of Arbitration Procedure for Customer Disputes.
This objection applies to each and every Request for Information.
7.
FTC asserts each of these general objections to each of the requests herein. FTC
also asserts specific objections to particular requests. The failure to assert a general objection to
a particular request does not constitute a waiver of any general objections. Subject to and
without waiving the above general objections to all paragraphs of the requests, FTC responds to
the individual requests as follows:
Documents Requested
1.
All documents or categories of documents referenced in the Guide at Document
Production List Two: Documents to Be Produced in All Customer Cases, and at Document
Production Lists Eight and Ten, identifying additional discoverable documents for cases alleging
misrepresentation/omission, and negligence/breach of fiduciary duty, respectively
Response:
FTC incorporates its separate response to the Discovery Guide Requests.
2.
All documents relied upon in drafting the Amended Statement of Claim.
Response:
FTC objects because this request invades the work-product and attorney
client privileges. To the extent such documents are responsive to other requests, FTC will
produce the responsive documents.
3.
All documents concerning allegations in the Amended Statement of Claim.
2
997243v1/011543
EFTA00731181
Response:
FTC objects because this request is overly broad, vague, and unduly
burdensome. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
4.
All documents concerning investments by Claimants in the Funds.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is overly broad, vague, and unduly
burdensome. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
5.
All documents concerning investments by Claimants in any Bear Stearns Fund.
Response: FTC objects because this request is overly broad, vague, unduly burdensome,
and not calculated to lead to the discovery of relevant information to the extent it seeks
information not related to the Funds at issue. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC will
produce responsive documents.
6.
All documents concerning investments by Claimants in the Funds on behalf of or
as trustee for any third party, including without limitation The Wexner Children's Trust II.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is overly broad, vague, and unduly
burdensome. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
7.
All documents concerning investments by Claimants in any Bear Stearns Fund on
behalf of or as trustee for any third party, including without limitation The Wexner Children's
Trust II.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is overly broad, vague, unduly
burdensome, and not calculated to lead to the discovery of relevant information to the extent it
seeks information not related to the Funds at issue. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC will
produce responsive documents.
8.
All documents concerning any statement by or on behalf of Respondents or any
Fund Manager concerning the Funds, including statements concerning the Funds' management,
operation, underlying investments or investment performance.
3
997243vI/011543
EFTA00731182
Response:
FTC will produce responsive documents.
9.
All documents concerning any communication between Claimants and
Respondents or any Fund Manager concerning the Funds.
Response:
FTC will produce responsive documents.
10.
All documents concerning any advice, recommendations, or analyses that
Claimants requested or received with respect to the Funds.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is overly broad, vague, and unduly
burdensome. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
11.
All documents concerning any advice, recommendations, or analyses that
Claimants requested or received concerning any actual, proposed or contemplated transaction
involving a limited partnership interest or other interest in the Funds.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is overly broad, vague, and unduly
burdensome. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
12.
All documents concerning any communications between Claimants and any other
investor in the Funds concerning the Funds.
Response:
FTC will produce responsive documents.
13.
All documents relied upon by Claimants in making their decisions to invest in the
Funds.
Response:
FTC will produce responsive documents.
14.
All documents concerning any actual, proposed or contemplated redemption or
sale of all or any portion of any of Claimants' shares or other ownership interests in the Funds.
4
997243vI/011543
EFTA00731183
Response:
FTC objects to the extent this requests seek information about transfers
after the events in question because such information is not relevant. Subject to the forgoing
objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
15.
All documents concerning any request by Claimants to redeem any shares or other
ownership interest in the Funds.
Response:
FTC will produce responsive documents.
16.
All documents concerning any other Bear Stearns Fund.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information and is overly burdensome.
17.
All documents concerning communications between Claimants and Respondents
concerning any other Bear Steams Fund.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information and is overly burdensome.
18.
All governing formation or organizational documents for Claimants that were in
effect at any time between July 1, 2003 and the present.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information and is calculated to harass Claimants.
19.
Documents sufficient to show all members, officers, directors and employees of
Claimants from July 1, 2003 until the present, including their (a) titles, and (b) duties and
responsibilities.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information and is calculated to harass Claimants.
20.
Documents sufficient to show all financial advisors or financial analysts
employed by Claimants from January 1, 2001 until the present.
5
997243v1/011543
EFTA00731184
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague, and is calculated to harass Claimants.
21.
Documents sufficient to show all employees, officers, directors, or trustees
involved in making investment decisions on behalf of Claimants.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague, and is calculated to harass Claimants.
Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC will produce responsive documents relating to the
investments in the Funds.
22.
Documents sufficient to show all entities and individuals for which or on whose
behalf Claimants have invested or managed funds from July 1, 2003 until the present.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague, and is calculated to harass Claimants
and its clients.
23.
Documents sufficient to show the complete educational and employment
background of (a) Jeffrey Epstein, (b) Harry Beller, (c) Darren Indyke, and (d) Lesley Groff.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information and is overly burdensome. Subject to the forgoing, FTC will produce
documents sufficient to show Mr. Epstein's educational and employment history to the extent
such documents are readily available to FTC.
24.
Documents sufficient to show Claimants' (a) overall assets, (b) investable assets,
and (c) earnings for the years 2003 to the present.
6
997243v11011543
EFTA00731185
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague, and is calculated to harass Claimants.
25.
All documents concerning the "financial consulting services" offered and
provided by FTC to third-parties as alleged on page 7 of the Amended Statelllent of Claim.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague, and is calculated to harass Claimants
and its clients.
26.
All documents concerning Claimants' actual, proposed or contemplated
investment guidelines, objectives, policies and/or strategies between July 1, 2003 and the
present.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague.
27.
All documents including, but not limited to, guidelines, protocols and manuals,
concerning Claimants' analyses, due diligence, portfolio monitoring and capabilities for analyses
concerning their investments.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC
will produce any responsive documents that may exist regarding the investments in the Funds.
28.
All documents concerning analyses, due diligence and portfolio monitoring
Claimants conducted concerning their investments from July 1, 2003 to the present.
7
997243v1/011543
EFTA00731186
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague, and is calculated to harass Claimants.
29.
All documents concerning analyses, due diligence and portfolio monitoring
Claimants conducted concerning the Funds from July 1, 2003 to the present.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is unduly vague. Subject to the forgoing
objection, FTC will produce responsive documents relating to FTC's investment in the Funds.
30.
All
documents
including
notes,
emails
and
memoranda
concerning
communications with respect to the Funds.
Response:
FTC objects because this request seeks information protected by the work-
produce and attorney-client privileges. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC will produce
responsive documents.
31.
To the extent not produced in response to Document Request No. I, all
documents concerning any ownership interest (whether beneficial, direct, indirect or otherwise)
that Claimants held in any hedge fund, private equity fund or other business entity, at any time
between January 1, 2001 and the present.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague, and is calculated to harass Claimants.
32.
To the extent not produced in response to Document Request No. I, all
documents concerning any actual, proposed or contemplated investment by or on behalf of
Claimants in any hedge fund, private equity fund or other business entity, at any time between
January 1, 2001 and the present.
8
997243v1/011543
EFTA00731187
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague, and is calculated to harass Claimants.
33.
To the extent not produced in response to Document Request No. I, all
documents concerning any investments made, or held by, or on behalf of Claimants or
investment accounts other than those concerning the Funds, from January I, 2001 to the present.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague, and is calculated to harass Claimants.
34.
All documents concerning Respondent Warren Spector ("Spector").
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC
will produce responsive documents relating to the Funds.
35.
All document concerning communications, from July 1, 2003 to the present,
between Claimants and Spector.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC
will produce responsive documents relating to the Funds.
36.
All documents concerning meetings, from July 1, 2003 to the present, between
Claimants and Spector.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC
will produce responsive documents relating to the Funds.
37.
All documents Claimants sent to or received from Spector, from July 1, 2003 to
the present.
9
997243v11011543
EFTA00731188
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC
will produce responsive documents relating to the Funds.
38.
All documents concerning communications, from July 1, 2003 to the present,
between Claimants and (a) Respondents, (b) any Fund Manager, (c) Evan Kerr, (d) Heather
Malloy, and (e) Ira Zicherman.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC
will produce responsive documents relating to the Funds.
39.
All documents concerning meetings, from July 1, 2003 to the present, between
Claimants and (a) Respondents, (b) any Fund Manager, (c) Evan Kerr, (d) Heather Malloy, and
(e) Ira Zicherman.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC
will produce responsive documents relating to the Funds.
40.
All documents concerning Claimants' communications with any other financial
advisors, investment advisors, or hedge fund managers, from January I, 2001 to the present.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague, and is calculated to harass Claimants.
41.
Documents sufficient to show all of the investments made or held by or on behalf
of Claimants from January I, 2001 to the present.
10
997243v11011543
EFTA00731189
Response:
FTC objects because this request is not calculated to lead to the discovery
of relevant information, is overly burdensome and vague, and is calculated to harass Claimants.
42.
All documents concerning Claimants' participation in or attendance (personally,
or via telephone or any other medium) at investor conference calls regarding the Funds or any
other Bear Steams Fund.
Response:
FTC objects to the extent this request seeks document unrelated to the
Funds as not calculated to lead to the discovery of relevant information. Subject to the forgoing,
FTC will produce responsive documents.
43.
All recordings or documents concerning recordings of any investor conference
calls or other telephone calls regarding the Funds or any other Bear Steams Fund.
Response:
FTC objects to the extent this request seeks document unrelated to the
Funds as not calculated to lead to the discovery of relevant information. Subject to the forgoing,
FTC will produce responsive documents.
44.
All documents concerning Claimants' participation in or attendance (personally,
or via telephone or any other medium) at any conference call or other presentation conducted by
or on behalf of any Bear Steams Entity or Fund Manager concerning (a) collateralized debt
obligation securities, (b) mortgage-backed securities, (c) asset-backed securities, (d)
securitization of mortgages, (e) the secondary market for trading in mortgage-backed products,
and (f) any type of security or asset held, directly or indirectly, by the Funds.
Response:
FTC objects to the extent this request seeks document unrelated to the
Funds as not calculated to lead to the discovery of relevant information. Subject to the forgoing
objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
45.
All documents concerning Claimants' attempts, if any, to obtain information
concerning the Funds' underlying investments.
11
997243v1/011543
EFTA00731190
Response:
Subject to the understanding this request only relates to the time period
before the Funds imploded, FTC will produce responsive documents.
46.
All documents concerning Claimants' knowledge concerning the Funds' subprime
exposure (whether direct or indirect).
Response:
Subject to the understanding this request only relates to the time period
before the Funds imploded, FTC will produce responsive documents.
47.
All documents concerning Claimants' knowledge of the Funds' underlying
investments and performance.
Response:
Subject to the understanding this request only relates to the time period
before the Funds imploded, FTC will produce responsive documents.
48.
All documents concerning Claimants' views of whether the Funds' exposure to
subprime mortgages was important to their decision to invest in the Funds or to hold onto their
investments in the Funds.
Response:
FTC will produce responsive documents.
49.
All documents concerning Claimants' attempts, if any, to obtain information
concerning the actual or potential risks of investing, directly or indirectly, in collateralized debt
obligations, collateralized mortgage obligations, mortgage-backed securities, asset-backed
securities, and the subprime market.
Response:
FTC objects to the extent this request seeks document unrelated to the
Funds as not calculated to lead to the discovery of relevant information. Subject to the forgoing
objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
50.
All documents concerning Claimants' views with respect to the risks involved in
investing, directly or indirectly, in collateralized debt obligations, collateralized mortgage
obligations, mortgage-backed securities, asset-backed securities and the subprime market.
12
997243vI/011543
EFTA00731191
Response:
FTC objects to the extent this request seeks document unrelated to the
Funds as not calculated to lead to the discovery of relevant information. Subject to the forgoing
objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
51.
All documents concerning any advice, recommendations, or analyses that
Claimants requested or received with respect to investments, direct or indirect, in collateralized
debt obligations, collateralized mortgage obligations, mortgage-backed securities, asset-backed
securities and the subprime market.
Response:
FTC objects to the extent this request seeks document unrelated to the
Funds as not calculated to lead to the discovery of relevant information. Subject to the forgoing
objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
52.
All documents concerning Claimants' reliance on statements, omissions, or
representations allegedly made by Respondents or any Fund Manager.
Response:
FTC objects to the extent this request seeks document unrelated to the
Funds as not calculated to lead to the discovery of relevant information. Subject to the forgoing
objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
53.
All documents concerning Claimants' claims for damages, including their claims
for compensatory damages, recessionary damages, interest, and punitive damages.
Response:
FTC objects because this request invades the work-product and attorney-
client privileges. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
54.
All documents concerning the allegation on page 3 of the Amended Statement of
Claim that "in reality, Respondents created the Enhanced Fund as part of a scheme both to
alleviate the looming liquidity problems that the High Grade Fund begun to encounter and to
13
997243vI/011543
EFTA00731192
facilitate fraudulent manipulations of fund portfolio values already taking place in the High
Grade Fund."
Response:
FTC objects because this request invades the work-product and attorney-
client privileges. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
55.
All documents concerning the allegations on page 4 of the Amended Statement of
Claim that "Respondent Spector . . . personally solicited FTC, through Epstein, to invest in the
Enhanced Fund, providing clearly misleading and false assurances about the Fund and its
investment safety . . . [and] bolstered this safety representation and secured Epstein's
unsuspecting confidence in Respondents' scheme by falsely claiming to have made his own
personal investment in the Fund."
Response:
FTC objects because this request invades the work-product and attorney-
client privileges. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
56.
All documents concerning the allegation on page 7 of the Amended Statement of
Claim that "[a]fler the ABS Fund collapsed, COUQ transferred its shared in the ABS Fund to
another charitable foundation, but COUQ did not transfer its legal claims."
Response:
FTC objects because this request invades the work-product and attorney-
client privileges. FTC further objects to this request as potentially seeking information not
calculated to lead to the discovery of relevant information. Subject to the forgoing objection,
FTC will produce the legal documents that memorialize the transfer.
57.
All documents concerning the allegation on page 9 of the Amended Statement of
Claim that "[f]or more than 26 years, Epstein invested millions of dollars in various Bear
Steams' [sic] sponsored investments, relying principally on the assurances, advice and
14
997243v1/011543
EFTA00731193
representations of Spector and other executives at the highest levels of Bear Steams'
management."
Response:
FTC objects because this request invades the work-product and attorney-
client privileges.
FTC further objects because this information is equally available to
Respondents and as to FTC and it is overly burdensome to require to produce the information to
Respondents. Subject to the forgoing objection, FTC will produce responsive documents.
58.
To the extent not called for by the preceding requests or by the applicable portions
of the Guide, all documents concerning (a) the Funds, (b) the Fund Managers, (c) Evan Kerr, (d)
Heather Malloy, (e) Ira Zicherman, (0 any other Bear Steams Fund, and (g) Respondents.
Response:
FTC objects because this request is vague, overly burdensome, and
potentially seeks information that not calculated to lead to the discovery of relevant information.
15
997243v1/011543
EFTA00731194
Information Requested
1.
Provide all information referenced in the Guide at Document Production List
Two: Documents to Be Produced in All Customer Cases, and at Document Production Lists
Eight and Ten, identifying additional discoverable information
for cases alleging
misrepresentation/omission and negligence/breach of fiduciary duty, respectively.
Response:
FTC objects because it cannot tell what the information request seeks. It
appears to violate FINRA 12507. FTC incorporates its Response to Discovery Guide requests.
2.
Identify each person with knowledge or information relevant to the subject matter
of the Amended Statement of Claim.
Response:
Jeffrey Epstein, Harry Beller, Warren Spector, James Cayne, Ralph Cioffi, Matthew
Tannin, Colin Gordon, and Franklin Collins.
3.
Identify each person relevant to the subject matter of the Amended Statement of
Claim.
Response:
Jeffrey Epstein, Harry Beller, Warren Spector, James Cayne, Ralph Cioffi, Matthew
Tannin, Colin Gordon, Franklin Collins, and all employees of the Funds.
4.
Identify all brokerage or investment accounts in which Claimants held any
ownership interest (whether direct, indirect, beneficial or otherwise) during the period January 1,
2001 to the present, by stating: (a) name of broker-dealer at which the account was maintained,
(b) date account was opened, (c) account number, (d) name of account holder, and (e) name of
any other person or entity that holds or held any ownership interest in the account.
16
997243v1/011543
EFTA00731195
Response:
FTC objects because this request seeks information that is not calculated
to lead to the discovery of relevant information. FTC further objects because this request
violation FINRA Rule 12507.
5.
Identify each meeting or telephone conversation in which Claimants and one or
more of the Respondents or Fund Managers participated.
Response:
FTC objects because this request seeks information that is not calculated
to lead to the discovery of relevant information to the extent it seeks information unrelated to the
Funds. FTC further objects because this request violation FINRA Rule 12507.
6.
Identify each person involved in making investment decisions on behalf of
Claimants at any time between January I, 2001 and the present.
Response:
FTC objects because this request seeks information that is not calculated
to lead to the discovery of relevant information to the extent it seeks information unrelated to the
Funds. FTC further objects because this request violation FINRA Rule 12507. Subject to the
forgoing objection, FTC's decisions regarding the investments in the Funds were made solely by
Jeffrey Epstein.
7.
Identify each person who provided investment advice to Claimants at any time
between January I, 2001 and the present.
Response:
FTC objects because this request seeks information that is not calculated
to lead to the discovery of relevant information to the extent it seeks information unrelated to the
Funds. FTC further objects because this request violation FINRA Rule 12507. Subject to the
forgoing objection, FTC received investment advice regarding the Funds from Warren Spector.
8.
Identify all financial advisors or financial analysts employed by Claimants from
January 1, 2001 until the present.
17
997243v11011543
EFTA00731196
Response:
FTC objects because this request seeks information that is not calculated
to lead to the discovery of relevant information to the extent it seeks information unrelated to the
Funds. FTC further objects because this request violation FINRA Rule 12507.
9.
State the educational background, academic degrees and credentials, and
professional licenses held by, and employment history of each person identified in response to
Information Request Nos. 6, 7, and 8, as well as (a) Jeffrey Epstein, (b) Harry Beller, (c) Darren
Indyke, and (d) Lesley Groff.
Response:
FTC objects because this request seeks information that is not calculated
to lead to the discovery of relevant information. FTC further objects because this request
violation FINRA Rule 12507.
10.
Identify each member, officer, director and employee of Claimants from July I,
2003 until the present, including their (a) titles, and (b) duties and responsibilities.
Response:
FTC objects because this request seeks information that is not calculated
to lead to the discovery of relevant information. FTC further objects because this request
violation FINRA Rule 12507.
II.
Identify all entities and individuals for which or on whose behalf Claimants have
invested or managed funds from July 1, 2003 until the present.
Response:
FTC objects because this request seeks information that is not calculated
to lead to the discovery of relevant information and is calculated to harass FTC and its clients.
FTC further objects because this request violation FINRA Rule 12507.
12.
Identify each bank account in which Claimants held any ownership interest
(whether direct, indirect, beneficial or otherwise) during the period January 1, 2001 to the
present, by: (a) identifying the bank or other financial institution at which such account is or was
maintained; (b) stating the account number for such account; and (c) identifying all persons who
18
997243v1/011543
EFTA00731197
held any ownership interest (whether direct, indirect, beneficial or otherwise) in such account
during the period January I, 2001 to the present.
Response:
FTC objects because this request seeks information that is not calculated
to lead to the discovery of relevant information. FTC further objects because this request
violation FINRA Rule 12507.
13.
For each of the following individuals, state the title of each periodical, including
magazines and newspapers to which each individual subscribed on or after the date of Claimants'
purchase of any limited partnership interest or other ownership interest in the Funds: (a) Jeffrey
Epstein, (b) Harry Beller, (c) Darren Indyke, and (d) Lesley Groff.
Response:
FTC objects because this request seeks information that is not calculated
to lead to the discovery of relevant information. FTC further objects because this request
violation FINRA Rule 12507.
Dated:
New York, New York
May
2010
Respectfully submitted,
SUSMAN GODFREY L.L.P.
Stephen D. Susman
654 Madison Avenue, 5th Floor
New York, New York 10065-8440
Tele hone:
Fax:
E-mail:
19
997243v11011543
EFTA00731198
Harry P. Susman
SUSMAN GODFREY
.
1000 Louisiana Street, Suite 5100
Houston, Texas 77002-5096
Telephone: (713) 651-9366
Fax: (713) 654-6666
E-mail:
Attorneys for Claimants
Financial Trust Company, Inc.
C.O.U.Q. Foundation
20
997243v1/011543
EFTA00731199
PROOF OF SERVICE
This is to certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing instrument has been served
by email and first class mail, this _th day of May, 2010, on:
Gabrielle Gould
KRAMER LEVIN NAFTAILIS & FRANKEL LLP
1177 Avenue of the Americas
New York, New York 10036
E-mail:
21
David B. Anders
Meredith L. Turner
WACHTELL, LIPTON, ROSEN & ICATz.
51 West 52nd Street
New York, New York 10019
E-mail:
E-mail:
Stephen D. Susman
997243v11011543
EFTA00731200
Document Preview
PDF source document
This document was extracted from a PDF. No image preview is available. The OCR text is shown on the left.
This document was extracted from a PDF. No image preview is available. The OCR text is shown on the left.
Extracted Information
Dates
Phone Numbers
Document Details
| Filename | EFTA00731180.pdf |
| File Size | 1085.0 KB |
| OCR Confidence | 85.0% |
| Has Readable Text | Yes |
| Text Length | 32,138 characters |
| Indexed | 2026-02-12T13:53:27.587222 |