Giuffre_Maxwell_Batch4_p00131.png

Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1328-6 Filed 01/05/24 Page 2 of 32 TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE NO. TABLE OF AUTHORITIES oo... cecceeeesescneeecseseeeeecseseescscseseescseseseeaesesesavaeeesesseaeeseeseees ili-v PRELIMINARY STATEMENT uu... .cccceccceceesescseesescseeeseseseeesseaceecesseseesecseceeacsseeesacseeesenseeeesaes 1 FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND... cccccccseeceeseeeeeeseeesesceeeetesseseeesanaeneeeeaes 4 I MS. GIUFFRE’S ALLEGED RELATIONSHIP WITH JEFFREY EPSTEIN AND BELATED ACCUSATIONS AGAINST PROFESSOR DERSHOWITZ... cceccceeecseeseseseeeeeseeeneeesseneeeeeeaeee 4 IL. MS. GIUFFRE AND HER ATTORNEYS’ CONTINUING INSISTENCE ON, AND REPETITION OF, ACCUSATIONS AGAINST PROFESSOR DERSHOWITZ... ccecccceeeseeseseseseeeceeseeeesseeeeeeesees 5 Il. THE EXCULPATORY EMAILS, REPLY BRIEF, AND MANUSCRIPT oo ccccecsescsesecsescseeeceeseseeecaeseseeessesseecsssessescaeeesanseneeesaneeeee 6 IV. THE REVELATION OF THE EXCULPATORY DOCUMENTS TO PROFESSOR DERSHOWITZ uuu... cccccceecsceeeseseeeesescseeeesesesececsesseesscseeeeaeseeeeeas 11 ARGUMENT 2. cecsecseseseseeseseseseescscsececseseeececsesauecscsesecacsesesesscsesesasaseesessesaesscseeeeasseeeeeasaes 11 I PROFESSOR DERSHOWITZ SHOULD BE PERMITTED TO INTERVENE UNDER FEDERAL RULE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 24(B) ue eee 11 A. There Is Significant Overlap Between the Subject Matter of the Original Action and This Motion 00.0... cece eeseseesessseeseseseeeneteees 12 B. There Is No Risk of Undue Delay or Prejudice... eeeeteeeeee 12 C. Professor Dershowitz Has a Compelling Interest in Access That Is Not Represented by Any Existing Party .........ccccseseseeseeeeeeeteeee 13 IL. THE FIRST AMENDMENT AND THE COMMON LAW REQUIRE PUBLIC ACCESS TO THE REQUESTED DOCUMENTS... eee 14 A. Legal Standard oo... eeceeescseesescseeeeseseseeeesesesecessesesecscseeeesseeeeesacseeeeas 14 1. The Common Law Test oe... ccccesceeeseseseeeeseessescseeeseeseseeesaeeenees 15 2. The First Amendment Test oo... ececeeeeecseseeeeecseeseeeseseeseseeees 15 B. The Requested Documents Are Judicial Documents... eee 16 C. The Common Law Right of Access Applies to the Requested Documents 2.0... ccs ceeeccescssecesceseseseescsecsecscescsecsesseseeseescsecsecseesceeesesseeseneeaeegs 17