Giuffre_Maxwell_Batch4_p00305.png

IL. Il. Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1328-18 Filed 01/05/24 Page 2 of 50 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page INTRODUCTION ooo cceeceeseseeecscseeecscsessescscseaeseseeecaesesesessesseecsesessescaseesanseneeeeas 1 DEFENDANT’S ENTIRE MOTION SHOULD BE DENIED... eee ett eeeeneeeeee 1 MOTION TO COMPEL RESPONSES TO INTERROGATORIES SHOULD BE DENIED 0c cceeeseeesceeseseseeescscsecaescseeesseseeececsessescseseaescaesecaeseneeesaeeececsesaesscseeeeasseneeeeas 2 A. Interrogatory NO. 5....cccecseseseeseeseseeseeseseeseecenecseeseeecsesseeseeeaeeaeeceaecaeeeseesaeeaeeeeeeaeerees 2 1. Ms. Giuffre’s Counsel’s Communications With the Media Are Outside the Scope of Rule 26 and Any Attempt at Collection Would be Unduly Burdensome .0....... cc cceeceeseeeeseseseeeeeeseseeeeecseseescaeeesenseneeesanees 2 2. Defendant is Already in Possession of Ms. Giuffre’s Communications With the Media... ceeccssescscseesescseseesescseeesseseecesseeeesscseeeseseesenseasees 3 B. Interrogatory NO. 6......:eccesessessesseeseceseeecsecsaeeeeseeseesseceeeceecnecsaesaeseeeeaesneseeeeseseeeeaees 5 C. Interrogatory NO. 7... ccececscesceseseeseesessesesscsecsecsceecsecsessesecseesesecsecsseseseesesseeeeseeaeeeee 8 D. Interrogatory NO. 8....ccccecsecessescessseeseesesseseeseecseeseeeceesseeseeeseeaeeceaesseeeseseeaeereeeatees 10 E. Interrogatory NO. 13 ...cceceecescessessseeseesesseseeseeeceeeseeecsesseeaeeeseeaeecenecseeeceeseeaeereeeatees 10 1. Ms. Giuffre Has Answered This Interrogatory Completely........0....0... 10 2. This Court Has Already Ruled Against Defendant on Pre-1999 Medical Records, so Defendant is Estopped From Bringing This ATQUMENE oe eecceseeseeeesecseeseseesceseeecsecaeesseecsecsesaeaceaeeaeesseesaeeaeeseaeeaeeasereaees 15 3. This Request is Overly Burdensome and Disallowed Under New York Law... ceccceseseesceseeeescsessesceeseeescseeecaeseseeecaeseeesssesseeeesseseecseeeeaes 17 4. The Physician-patient Privilege Applies to These Documents ................ 19 F. Interrogatory NO. 14... ececescesceseseeseesesseseeseecseeseeecesseeaeeeseeaeeaesecseeeseeseeaeereeeaeees 20 1. This Discovery is Barred by FRE 412.0... ccccececeeeseeseeeeteeeeeeeeeeseeeeeeeeees 20 2. This Request if Propounded for Improper Purposes and Harassment......21 3. This Request Seeks Irrelevant Information .........0. ccc ee eeeeeeeeees 22