Giuffre_Maxwell_Batch4_p00594.png

Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP Document 1328-41 Filed 01/05/24 Page 2 of 31 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page TABLE OF AUTHORITIES 00... ccc cccecceececseseesescseseesescseeecaesenececsesseecsesesaescaesesaeseaseesesseseaseees ii L INTRODUCTION o.oo cece ceescceecseseeeeecseseeececseseescsesesanscseecaeseneeecaesaeecesseseeecaeeesaneas 1 IL FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND... ci ccccecccse esses eeeseseeeteceeeeesens 3 A. [REDACTED ]......sscesssessssesssessssessseesssesssvesssesssessaressseesasesssestssessssssasesssssasessseesssessseees 3 B. The Litigation Involving Dershowitz - The Florida Defamation Case...........0.0... 5 IL DERSHOWITZ RELEASES CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION IN VIOLATION OF A FLORIDA COURT ORDER 200... ceeseeeeseseseeeceeseeescseesaeseneeecaeseseeesseseeesesaees 8 Ill. ©THE PROTECTIVE ORDER IN THIS CASE woo. cecececceesceeeeeeseseeesseseesesseseeesens 9 TV. ARGUMENT occ cccecsescsceececseseeecsesseecseseseescseseaeseneeecaesesesessesseecasseasecaesesatseneeeeas 0 A. Legal Standard oo... ccecseeeecseceesescseeecsescneeecseseeeessesseecessessescsseesseesseseeeseeseea 0 B. These Are Not Judicial Documents and Therefore Should Not be Disclosed...... 1 Cc. Even Were the Court to Deem the Documents to be Judicial Documents, the Presumption of Access is Weak......cccccceccessesssseseeeeseeseescsecseeeceesseeseeeeateaeereaeeaeenenes 5 D. No Right of Access Exists Under the First Amendment 0.0... 8 E. The Second Circuit Has a Presumption Against Modifying Protective Orders Upon Which Parties Reasonably Relied ..0..... ccc eeseeseseseeeescseeeeseseseeesaeeenees 20 1. The Record in this Case Shows That the Protective Order Was Not Improvidently Granted oo... es eseeeeeceeeeeecseesescseeeesseseeeseeeneneeaes 20 2. The Parties and Deponents in This Case Have Reasonably Relied Upon the Protective Order oo... cece ese eeceseeeeceeseeesssesseecesseeescseeessnseeeesaeees 21 3. Dershowitz Seeks These Materials For an Illegitimate Purpose Which Disqualifies Him from Relief... ccceceseeeeseeseeeeseeseeeceeeaeeseeeeseeeeneeneeeees 22 4. Under This Court’s Order, Non-Parties Cannot Challenge Confidentiality Designations and Dershowitz has Already Agreed to be Bound by the Parties’ Confidentiality Designations .0........ cee ee eeeeeeeeeneeeeeeteneeeeaes 24 V. CONCLUSION Woe cece ce cece eecseseeseseseesescseeecsescnececseseeecscsseecaeseseescaesesanseseeesaeeaeeseeaee 25