HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_010789.jpg

own on Win BW DY FH ow on nm PB WH NNNNN NER PE BR PP Be Be OBRWNP OM OYA MN RW NH O than three years after Virginia Roberts left for -- BY MR. SCAROLA: Q. Mr. Dershowitz -- MR. SCOTT: You're cutting the witness off. MR. SCAROLA: He's not answering my question, Tom. MR. SCOTT: Well -- MR. SCAROLA: I want to know whether the last name is spelled the same or it isn’t spelled the same on the flight log marked as an exhibit and on the photographs. That's a very direct question. It calls for a very direct yes or no response. And this witness has demonstrated a clear refusal to respond directly to direct questions, which will result, when we resume this deposition, in our requesting that the Court appoint a special master so that this deposition doesn't take two weeks to complete. MR. SCOTT: You know, Mr. Scarola, that's a nice speech and I appreciate it. MR. SCAROLA: Thank you. MR. SCOTT: I don't agree with your 203 BY MR. SCAROLA: Q. Is the last name on the photograph spelled exactly the same way as the last name on the flight log? A. If you're talking about a flight log that 1 was not on that flight, the answer is yes. Q. Allright. Thank you very nwch, sir. Now, that flight log also shows you flying repeatedly in the company of a woman named Tatiana, correct? A. I've only seen one reference to Tatiana on November 17. If you want to show me any other references, I'd be happy to look at them. Q. Allright, sir. Thank you. Let's go back to the —~ MR. SCOTT: Are we done with this exhibit? MR. SCAROLA: We are done with the exhibit. MR. SCOTT: Okay. Then let's collect the exhibits so that we don't have a big -- then we'll turn them over to the court reporter to keep safekeeping. There you go, young lady, don't lose those, don't get them wet. And we'll proceed. characterization. And if you recall, months ago I suggested a special master for this deposition, for your clients’ depositions and for Virginia Roberts’ and your response to me was: I'll consider it, I won't pay for it. If your client wants to pay for it -- so basically you blew me off. So, I appreciate you finally come around. And your clients. MR. SCAROLA: Your client's misconduct has clearly convinced me, having now considered it, that it is absolutely necessary. MR. SCOTT: Okay. Now -- BY MR. SCAROLA: Q. So new could I get an answer to my question ~~ MR. SCOTT: Now that we have -- BY MR. SCAROLA: Q. -- whether the last name on the flight log is spelled exactly the same way as the last name in the photographs? MR. SCOTT: Now that all the lawyers' speeches are done, read the question back and the witness will answer it. MR. SCAROLA: | will repeat the question. 204 BY MR. SCAROLA: Q. Did you state during the same interview, the CNN Don Lemon interview: "She has said that Bill Clinton was with her at an orgy on Jeffrey's island"? A. I did state that, yes. Q. Was that statement intended as fact, opinion, or was it intended as rhetorical hyperbole? MR. SCOTT: Do you understand the question? THE WITNESS: Yes, I do. A. It was a statement based on what I believed were the facts at the time I said them, Various newspapers and blogs had placed Bill Clinton on, quote, "orgy island" on -- in the presence of Jeffrey Epstein when there were orgies. And at the time | made that statement, | hada belief that she had accused Bill Clinton of participating or being -- as being a part of or an observer or -- or a witness or a participant in orgies on what was called Jeffrey Epstein's orgy island. That was my state of belief, honest belief at the time I made that statement. BY MR. SCAROLA: Q. Yes, sir, And what I want to knew is what 7 (Pages 201 to 204) www. phippsreporting.com (888) 811-3408 HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_010789