HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015593.jpg

As set forth in Dershowitz’s Motion for Clarification of Confidentiality Order or Relief from that Order, filed Jan. 29, 2016, it appears that Roberts made false statements in a publicly filed affidavit about being present at a private island in the US Virgin Islands when former President Clinton was there. Indeed, former FBI Director Louis Freeh determined based on the response of the federal government to a FOIA request that the absence of records responsive to the request “strongly establishes that former President Clinton was not present on Little St. James Island during the period at issue.” /d. at 2. If Roberts made a false statement under oath about former President Clinton, it is equally if not more likely that she has made false statements about others whose whereabouts are more difficult to track. Roberts cannot reasonably argue her testimony is confidential as Rn § See Excerpts of Roberts’s Deposition Transcript, attached hereto (under seal) as Exhibit F.' i IT ee Pe See id.; see also March 2, 2011, Sharon Churcher, Daily Mail, attached hereto as Exhibit G. Dershowitz has also discovered that Roberts Sec Exhibit F; see also AD-006931-006933, Transcript of Telephone Conversation Between Alan M. Dershowitz and Rebecca, attached hereto as Exhibit H. As a result, Roberts cannot claim that these allegations are confidential simply because IT TTT " As per the Confidentiality Order, Exhibit F is only filed under seal. HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015593