DOJ-OGR-00009694.jpg

Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 642 Filed 03/11/22 Page 2 of 66 Table of Contents PCIE og il, i QLD LS ASST ACUTE « co zon.smmmaronne ens. nme TON ER 88 AO SRA iv Te coxa eosem.comnsnonen a. SANNA AER. MN 2 NN . e 1 Peart], Berit wes sns.snr.s en. sos sn. wa 0 a AAA AS AD ASE WA SORA AS SE EWA ALBA ORI AT 2 DT Fan pF SRST cesses cos sn. scns as waa a 20s MLAS SE GE NASAL AS SER ETA ALAS LATA 2 Broo “TES TUE QUSSUMGTTEIELII SS, wes ss sas. was a 8.05.08 ON. SE Ta INSTAL AS ER EWA ALAS RIEL A 2 B. Juror No. 50’s questionnaire. ............ceeeceeeceeseeceseeeencecaeeesceeessecsneesseecsasenseeessaeeneees 5 C. Juror No. 5078 VOEr Cire... ceeeceeeceeeecceseceensecesecesncecssccesneecssecsneesacecsaseesseecsacesseeessaeensees 6 D. The final composition of the JULY. 0.0.0... cee eeeeeceseeeeneeceseeeseeeeeeeceeeesseecsaeenseeessaeeeees 9 II. Juror No. 50’s admissions that he wasn’t truthful with the Coutt..........0.. eee 11 A. Juror No. 50’s statements to the media... eee eeeceeeeeceeeceeeeecneeceneesneeceaeeeeeees 12 1. The interview with the Independent. ....0..0.. eee eeeeeeseceeeeecneceeeeeeneeceeereneeenes 12 2. The interview with the Daily Mal. .00.... eee eeeeeeeeceeeceeececeeeceeeeeessecsseersaeernes 13 3. The interview with Reuters... eee eeseceeeeeeneecescceseeecssecssnersneecsaseesneeeaeesees 14 4. The partial video of the interview with the Daily Mail... ee eeeeeeeeee eee 14 B. Juror No. 50’s social media activity. 0.0... eee eeeeeseeceeeeeenseceeeeeeeeeceseeeseeeesaeeseneees 15 C. A second juror admits to disclosing during deliberations that they were a victim of SOXUA] ASSAUIE. oo... elec ete ese cneecsecsaecsaecseecsaeeseesseesseesaeesaeesseesseessessseeseeeeerseenaeenes 21 Applicable Law..........eecceescesscecesecesececssecesceesnsecssceesseecsacensneesssecsnersneecaseesaeecsaeesseeesnaessnee® 21 I. Juror No. 50’s misconduct deprived Ms. Maxwell of her constitutional right to a fair trial by an impartial JULY. 00.0... eee eeeeeeeeecsneceseeecssecssceesseecsaeeesaeecsaecesneecsaeceseersneeraeeesneees 21 A. A party alleging unfairness based on undisclosed juror bias must demonstrate first, that the juror’s voir dire response was false and second, that the correct response would have provided a valid basis for a challenge for CaUSe. ............eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee 21 DOJ-OGR- 00009694