DOJ-OGR-00009695.jpg

Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE Document 642 Filed 03/11/22 Page 3 of 66 B. An intentionally false answer during voir dire is not a prerequisite to obtaining a NOW trial. ooeecc eee ceeeeeecccccessecccceseccccesescccccsscecccsuseececcsssececesseseecceseseescessarsceesuenescess 23 SCT ORIERROIAL se, sa svn... 5s sa. 008.1.53 0 SI STR SAN OSE ASAE ORS. 2A AE WOR SSAA LAD SIBLE A AA ES 28 I. Ms. Maxwell is entitled to a new trial. vo... eee eee eeeeseececceeeeccccccseececceneeccccseeneecees 28 A. Juror No. 50 did not truthfully answer material questions during voir dire, THelocirens Chas ttris 2S GEL AR eres com.cn cmmomens wksem.emmmenom 2. mma i. ARAN 28 B. Had Juror No. 50 answered Questions 25 and 48 truthfully, his answers would have provided a valid basis for a challenge for CaUSE. ...........:eeeceeeeeeeeceeeeeeneeeeeeee 29 1. Irphied Dias, ooo eee eeeeeeseceeeeeeseeceseeesceeesaecnseeesseecsseeesseessaeeeseeesaaecseereneeenas 30 VCO) 37 Be ABO) DIGS, ce ccrsensonas smscenomesioens sms umnenauntns Satis SEMRURRIURIR UI I SEHURAIURISS HOG ATS SUIRURIRURERG AES so 38 C. Juror No. 50’s answers to Questions 25 and 48 were intentionally false............... 39 D. Had Juror No. 50 answered Questions 25 and 48 truthfully, the parties and the Court would have explored whether his other answers were false. ..............:.::0 43 E. The scope of any evidentiary hearing. ..............eeeceeeseceeceeneeceeneesseeceeeeseeeraseeseeees 48 1. Pre-hearing disCOVETY. ...........:ceeeceeseceseceeeeeeseceeceesseecsseceseeecsaseeseeeensecasereneereas 48 2. The hearing itself. 0... eee eeeceeececesecesneecaeceseersneecesseesaeecsaecsseeesssecseersneereas 49 TL. Jane Ne. 30 hae no Tht te MSPS, os cecommnnms exrem.eneannonen exscmnemeamaonmy emcee ema. 51 An AOE Ti, SO Teche SUE cercmono amen cmmomenn wansemememteNn ais. RRR Ss RENAN 51 This Court should refuse Juror No. 50’s discovery request because Juror No. 50 is under investigation and the release of the information requested would prejudice that INVESTIGATION. ......... eee eeeeeeseeceeceeeececeeeeseeecsaccesceecssecseeesseeceaseesaeecaseseeeesaeeneee® 52 C. Juror No. 50’s filings should be stricken or, alternatively, remain under seal. ...... 53 COMNCIUSION «00.0... ce cescesecesecesecnsecnsccssecssccssecssccssccssccssecsaccsaecsaecssecsaecsascsaecsaecsaeeseesnseesseaeesae® 56 Certificate Of Service oo... eee eecsscssecssecnsecssecsecsecssecssccsaecsaecssecsaecsaecssecnaesseesneseseseseeaeenaes 59 ili DOJ-OGR-00009695